Exposure assessment
In this guide
In this guideOn this page
Skip the menu of subheadings on this page.Methodology
Grains
28. Exposure assessments were conducted on a survey population basis using consumption data and the corresponding LB and UB median occurrence values. Median occurrence levels were calculated for the sum of T-2 and HT-2 toxins (µg/kg) to avoid skewing the overall exposure, due to the wide concentration range of the reported occurrence levels. This was applied to all grains and the exposure “scenarios” were as follows:
- Oat grains only,
- All grains; and,
- Ready To Eat (RTE).
29. A single food group was created, comprising of all the potential sources of oat consumption in NDNS food groups, for estimating exposure to the sum of T-2 and HT-2 from consumption of oat grains only (Tables 2-5). Exposure to the sum of T-2 and HT-2 from this food group was estimated from NDNS consumption data, using occurrence estimates under the following scenarios:
- Unprocessed oat grains,
- Unprocessed oat grains after application of a reduction factor of 85%,
- Processed oat grains (submitted by industry as ‘already processed'); and,
- “Oats combined” (the amalgamation of the occurrence data described in the second and third bullet points above).
30. Additional food groups were created for estimating exposure to the sum of T-2 and HT-2 from consumption of cereal grains other than oat grains, no reduction factors were identified for these cereal grains. The following scenarios were applied:
a) Unprocessed wheat grains,
b) Processed wheat grains,
c) Unprocessed barley grains; and,
d) Processed barley grains.
31. Acute and chronic exposures for all grains (Tables 6-9) were estimated for the sum of T-2 and HT-2 (mean and 97.5th percentile).
Ready To Eat (RTE) foods
32. For RTE foods, the exposure assessments were on a consumer basis using mean and maximum occurrence levels. The data was verified by applying the same inclusion criteria as for grains (described in paragraph 13).
33. Chronic and acute exposures to individual toxins (T-2 or HT-2) (mean and 97.5th percentile) were calculated using the mean and maximum concentration of either T-2 or HT-2 occurrence data. Estimated exposures to the sum of T-2 and HT-2 were only calculated for infant cereal, as this was the only food category for which data was available for the sum of T-2 and HT-2. Mean and maximum occurrence levels were used, as the datasets were not sufficient to calculate the median for the sum of the respective mycotoxin.
Consumption data
34. Consumption data from the NDNS (Bates et al., 2014, 2016, 2020; Roberts et al., 2018), as well as the Diet and Nutrition Survey of Infants and Young Children (DNSIYC) (Department of Health, 2011) were used for the exposure assessments.
35. The grain food groups used for this assessment were derived by mapping FoodEx2 codes onto NDNS and DNSIYC food codes using an inhouse FSA recipes database. Consumption and subsequent exposures were calculated for the following population groups:
- Infants (4-18 months).
- Toddlers (1.5-3 years).
- Children (4-10 years).
- Older children (11-18 years).
- Adults (19-64 years).
- Older adults (≥ 65 years).
- Adult vegetarians/vegans (19-64 years); and,
- Women of childbearing age (16-49 years).
36. For the RTE food groups, each group was derived from FoodEx2 codes. These codes were searched in the FSA recipe database to identify and match NDNS and DNSIYC food codes. The consumption and subsequent estimated exposure for RTEs were calculated in the following population groups:
- Infants (4-18 months).
- Toddlers (1.5-3 years).
- Adults (19-64 years old); and,
- Adult vegetarians/vegans (19-64 years).
37. However, where infant RTE foods only were available, consumption and subsequent estimated exposures were calculated in infants and toddlers only.
Results
38. Chronic and acute exposure estimates are presented in Tables 2-9 (cereal grains) and Tables 10-13 (RTE). These tables summarise the mean and 97.5th percentile exposure to the sum of T-2 and HT-2 for the different cereal grains or T-2 or HT-2 for RTE foods.
Unprocessed oat grains
Chronic exposure
39. Table 2 provides chronic exposure estimates resulting from the application of a reduction factor of 85% to unprocessed oat grains. After application of the reduction factor, the lowest exposures were in older children (11-18 years), with mean and 97.5th percentile exposures of 0.0014-0.0019 (LB-UB) and 0.0098-0.013 (LB-UB) µg/kg body weight (bw), respectively; the highest exposures were in infants and toddlers, where UB exposures at the 97.5th percentiles were up to 0.05 µg/kg bw/day.
40. Estimated exposures from unprocessed oat grains have been included in Table 2 for comparison, with a UB 97.5th percentile exposure of up to 0.29 µg/kg bw in infants (4-18 months) and toddlers (1.5-3 years; 0.28 µg/kg bw).
Table 1: Chronic exposures to sum of T-2 and HT-2 from unprocessed oat grains and unprocessed oat grains with a reduction factor applied (µg/kg bw/day; LB-UB). Consumption data was based on DNSYIC and NDNS years 1-11, occurrence data was collected from the FSA’s call for evidence.
Infants (4-18 months) (n=2683)
Food groups |
Count of T-2 HT-2 data call samples (n) |
Median T-2/HT-2 concentration µg/kg LB-UB |
Mean* |
P97.5* |
Unprocessed oats** |
4083 |
170.44 |
0.047 |
0.29 |
Unprocessed oats with reduction factor+ |
4083 |
22.20-30.00 |
0.0061-0.0083 |
0.038-0.051 |
Toddlers (1.5-3 years) (n=1157)
Food groups |
Count of T-2 HT-2 data call samples (n) |
Median T-2/HT-2 concentration µg/kg LB-UB |
Mean* |
P97.5* |
Unprocessed oats** |
4083 |
170.44 |
0.044 |
0.28 |
Unprocessed oats with reduction factor+ |
4083 |
22.20-30.00 |
0.0058 – 0.0078 |
0.037 – 0.050 |
Children (4-10 years) (n=2537)
Food groups |
Count of T-2 HT-2 data call samples (n) |
Median T-2/HT-2 concentration µg/kg LB-UB |
Mean* |
P97.5*
|
Unprocessed oats** |
4083 |
170.44 |
0.028 |
0.17 |
Unprocessed oats with reduction factor+ |
4083 |
22.20-30.00 |
0.0037 – 0.0050 |
0.023 – 0.031 |
Older Children (11-18 years) (n=2657)
Food groups |
Count of T-2 HT-2 data call samples (n) |
Median T-2/HT-2 concentration µg/kg LB-UB |
Mean* |
P97.5* |
Unprocessed oats** |
4083 |
170.44 |
0.011 |
0.076 |
Unprocessed oats with reduction factor+ |
4083 |
22.20-30.00 |
0.0014 – 0.0019 |
0.0098 – 0.013 |
Adults (19-64 years) (n=5094)
Food groups |
Count of T-2 HT-2 data call samples (n) |
Median T-2/HT-2 concentration µg/kg LB-UB |
Mean* |
P97.5* |
Unprocessed oats** |
4083 |
170.44 |
0.014 |
0.095 |
Unprocessed oats with reduction factor+ |
4083 |
22.20-30.00 |
0.0018 – 0.0024 |
0.012 – 0.017 |
Elderly (65+ years) (n=1538)
Food groups |
Count of T-2 HT-2 data call samples (n) |
Median T-2/HT-2 concentration µg/kg LB-UB |
Mean* |
P97.5* |
Unprocessed oats** |
4083 |
170.44 |
0.020 |
0.10 |
Unprocessed oats with reduction factor+ |
4083 |
22.20-30.00 |
0.0026 – 0.0035 |
0.013 – 0.018 |
Adult Vegetarians / Vegans (19-64 years) (n=170)
Food groups |
Count of T-2 HT-2 data call samples (n) |
Median T-2/HT-2 concentration µg/kg LB-UB |
Mean* |
P97.5* |
Unprocessed oats** |
4083 |
170.44 |
0.024 |
0.14 |
Unprocessed oats with reduction factor+ |
4083 |
22.20-30.00 |
0.0031 – 0.0042 |
0.018 – 0.025 |
Women of Childbearing age (16-49 years) (n=2556)
Food groups |
Count of T-2 HT-2 data call samples (n) |
Median T-2/HT-2 concentration µg/kg LB-UB |
Mean* |
P97.5* |
Unprocessed oats** |
4083 |
170.44 |
0.012 |
0.081 |
Unprocessed oats with reduction factor+ |
4083 |
22.20-30.00 |
0.0016 – 0.0022 |
0.011 – 0.014 |
*Estimates have been rounded to 2 significant figures.
**Unprocessed oat grains- oat grains without processing (raw primary commodity (RPC)).
+ Oat grains with reduction factor - unprocessed oat grains with reduction factor (85%) applied.
LB - Lower bound: values below the limit of quantification (LOQ) are treated as zero; UB - Upper bound: values below the LOQ are treated as at the LOQ.
** If single value is shown, it indicates that the exposures are based on detected values above the LOQ.
Acute exposure
41. Table 3 provides acute exposure estimates resulting from the application of a reduction factor of 85% to the occurrence data for unprocessed oat grains. After application of the reduction factor, the lowest exposures were in women of childbearing age (16-49 years) with mean and 97.5th percentile exposures of 0.0032-0.0043 (LB-UB) and 0.019-0.026 (LB-UB) µg/kg bw, respectively. The highest exposures were in infants (4-18 months) with mean and 97.5th percentile exposures of 0.013-0.018 (LB-UB) and 0.075-0.10 (LB-UB) µg/kg bw, respectively.
42. Without the application of a reduction factor to unprocessed oat grains, the highest acute exposures were seen in infants (4-18 months) with mean and 97.5th percentile exposures of 0.10 and 0.58 µg/kg bw, and toddlers with mean and 97.5th percentile exposures of 0.096 and 0.54 µg/kg bw, respectively.
Table 2: Acute exposure to the sum of T-2 and HT-2 from unprocessed oat grains and unprocessed oat grains with applied reduction factor based on DNSYIC and NDNS years 1-11 consumption data and occurrence data collected from the FSA call for evidence (µg/kg bw/day; LB-UB).
Infants (4-18 months) (n=2683)
Food groups |
Count of T-2 HT-2 data call samples (n) |
Median T-2/HT-2 concentration µg/kg LB-UB |
Mean* |
P97.5* |
Unprocessed oats** |
4083 |
170.44 |
0.10 |
0.58 |
Unprocessed oats with reduction factor+ |
4083 |
22.20-30.00 |
0.013-0.018 |
0.075-0.10 |
Toddlers (1.5-3 years) (n=1157)
Food groups |
Count of T-2 HT-2 data call samples (n) |
Median T-2/HT-2 concentration µg/kg LB-UB |
Mean* |
P97.5* |
Unprocessed oats** |
4083 |
170.44 |
0.096 |
0.54 |
Unprocessed oats with reduction factor+ |
4083 |
22.20-30.00 |
0.013 – 0.017 |
0.070 – 0.094 |
Children (4-10 years) (n=2537)
Food groups |
Count of T-2 HT-2 data call samples (n) |
Median T-2/HT-2 concentration µg/kg LB-UB |
Mean* |
P97.5*
|
Unprocessed oats** |
4083 |
170.44 |
0.063 |
0.33 |
Unprocessed oats with reduction factor+ |
4083 |
22.20-30.00 |
0.0081 – 0.011 |
0.043 – 0.059 |
Older Children (11-18 years) (n=2657)
Food groups |
Count of T-2 HT-2 data call samples (n) |
Median T-2/HT-2 concentration µg/kg LB-UB |
Mean* |
P97.5* |
Unprocessed oats** |
4083 |
170.44 |
0.025 |
0.16 |
Unprocessed oats with reduction factor+ |
4083 |
22.20-30.00 |
0.0033 – 0.0045 |
0.021 – 0.028 |
Adults (19-64 years) (n=5094)
Food groups |
Count of T-2 HT-2 data call samples (n) |
Median T-2/HT-2 concentration µg/kg LB-UB |
Mean* |
P97.5* |
Unprocessed oats** |
4083 |
170.44 |
0.026 |
0.15 |
Unprocessed oats with reduction factor+ |
4083 |
22.20-30.00 |
0.0034 – 0.0046 |
0.020 – 0.027 |
Elderly (65+ years) (n=1538)
Food groups |
Count of T-2 HT-2 data call samples (n) |
Median T-2/HT-2 concentration µg/kg LB-UB |
Mean* |
P97.5* |
Unprocessed oats** |
4083 |
170.44 |
0.032 |
0.15 |
Unprocessed oats with reduction factor+ |
4083 |
22.20-30.00 |
0.0042 – 0.0057 |
0.019 – 0.026 |
Adult Vegetarians / Vegans (19-64 years) (n=170)
Food groups |
Count of T-2 HT-2 data call samples (n) |
Median T-2/HT-2 concentration µg/kg LB-UB |
Mean* |
P97.5* |
Unprocessed oats** |
4083 |
170.44 |
0.047 |
0.24 |
Unprocessed oats with reduction factor+ |
4083 |
22.20-30.00 |
0.0061 – 0.0082 |
0.031 – 0.042 |
Women of Childbearing age (16-49 years) (n=2556)
Food groups |
Count of T-2 HT-2 data call samples (n) |
Median T-2/HT-2 concentration µg/kg LB-UB |
Mean* |
P97.5* |
Unprocessed oats** |
4083 |
170.44 |
0.024 |
0.15 |
Unprocessed oats with reduction factor+ |
4083 |
22.20-30.00 |
0.0032 – 0.0043 |
0.019 – 0.026 |
*Estimates have been rounded to 2 significant figures.
**Unprocessed oat grains- oat grains without processing (raw primary commodity (RPC)).
+ Oat grains with reduction factor - unprocessed oat grains with reduction factor (85%) applied.
LB - Lower bound: values below the limit of quantification (LOQ) are treated as zero; UB - Upper bound: values below the LOQ are treated as at the LOQ.
** If single value is shown, it indicates that the exposures are based on detected values above the LOQ.
Processed grains and oats combined
43. The data presented in Tables 4 and 5 provide exposures from processed oat grains, as provided via the call for evidence, unprocessed oat grains with a reduction factor applied (85%) and oats combined. Oats combined, which are unprocessed oats with a reduction factor applied plus processed oats (see paragraph 29) reflect a more realistic exposure scenario for the UK population, taking account of any occurrence data of processed oat grains submitted by industry (small overall number) and unprocessed oats to which a reduction factor has been applied (the majority of the data).
Chronic exposure
44. Table 4 shows chronic exposures from oat grains, i.e. processed oat grains, unprocessed oat grains with a reduction factor applied and oats combined.
45. The lowest chronic exposures for processed oat grains were for older children (11-18 years), with mean and P97.5th percentile exposures of 0.0016 and 0.011 µg/kg bw, respectively while the highest chronic exposures were in infants (4-18 months) with mean and P97.5th percentile of 0.0069 and 0.043 µg/kg bw, respectively.
46. For oats combined, the lowest chronic exposures were in older children (11-18 years) with mean and 97.5th percentile of 0.0015-0.0019 (LB-UB) and 0.010-0.013 (LB-UB) µg/kg bw, respectively, while the highest chronic exposures were in infants (4-18 months) with mean and 97.5th percentile of 0.0063-0.0083 (LB-UB) and 0.039-0.051 (LB-UB) µg/kg bw, respectively. Toddlers (1.5-3 years) had similar exposures to infants.
47. The application of a reduction factor to unprocessed oat grains resulted in similar exposures to those reported for processed oat grains submitted by industry. This observation supports the choice of the reduction factor that was applied to unprocessed oat grains.
Table 3: Chronic exposure to the sum of T-2 and HT-2 from processed oat grains, unprocessed oat grains with applied reduction factor, and oats combined based on DNSYIC and NDNS years 1-11 consumption data and occurrence data collected from the FSA call for evidence (µg/kg bw/day; LB-UB).
Infants (4-18 months) (n=2683)
Food groups |
Count of T-2 HT-2 data call samples (n) |
Median T-2/HT-2 concentration µg/kg LB-UB |
Mean* |
P97.5* |
Processed oats** |
443 |
25 |
0.0069 |
0.043 |
Unprocessed oats with reduction factor+ |
4083 |
22.20-30.00 |
0.0061-0.0083 |
0.038-0.051 |
Oats combined ++ |
4526 |
22.95 – 30.00 |
0.0063-0.0083 |
0.039-0.051 |
Toddlers (1.5-3 years) (n=1157)
Food groups |
Count of T-2 HT-2 data call samples (n) |
Median T-2/HT-2 concentration µg/kg LB-UB |
Mean* |
P97.5* |
Processed oats** |
443 |
25 |
0.0065 |
0.042 |
Unprocessed oats with reduction factor+ |
4083 |
22.20-30.00 |
0.0058 – 0.0078 |
0.037 – 0.050 |
Oats combined ++ |
4526 |
22.95 – 30.00 |
0.0060 – 0.0078 |
0.038 – 0.050 |
Children (4-10 years) (n=2537)
Food groups |
Count of T-2 HT-2 data call samples (n) |
Median T-2/HT-2 concentration µg/kg LB-UB |
Mean* |
P97.5*
|
Processed oats** |
443 |
25 |
0.0042 |
0.025 |
Unprocessed oats with reduction factor+ |
4083 |
22.20-30.00 |
0.0037 – 0.0050 |
0.023 – 0.031 |
Oats combined ++ |
4526 |
22.95 – 30.00 |
0.0038 – 0.0050 |
0.023 – 0.031 |
Older Children (11-18 years) (n=2657)
Food groups |
Count of T-2 HT-2 data call samples (n) |
Median T-2/HT-2 concentration µg/kg LB-UB |
Mean* |
P97.5* |
Processed oats** |
443 |
25 |
0.0016 |
0.011 |
Unprocessed oats with reduction factor+ |
4083 |
22.20-30.00 |
0.0014 – 0.0019 |
0.0098 – 0.013 |
Oats combined ++ |
4526 |
22.95 – 30.00 |
0.0015 – 0.0019 |
0.010 – 0.013 |
Adults (19-64 years) (n=5094)
Food groups |
Count of T-2 HT-2 data call samples (n) |
Median T-2/HT-2 concentration µg/kg LB-UB |
Mean* |
P97.5* |
Processed oats** |
443 |
25 |
0.0020 |
0.014 |
Unprocessed oats with reduction factor+ |
4083 |
22.20-30.00 |
0.0018 – 0.0024 |
0.012 – 0.017 |
Oats combined ++ |
4526 |
22.95 – 30.00 |
0.0019 – 0.0024 |
0.013 – 0.017 |
Elderly (65+ years) (n=1538)
Food groups |
Count of T-2 HT-2 data call samples (n) |
Median T-2/HT-2 concentration µg/kg LB-UB |
Mean* |
P97.5* |
Processed oats** |
443 |
25 |
0.0029 |
0.015 |
Unprocessed oats with reduction factor+ |
4083 |
22.20-30.00 |
0.0026 – 0.0035 |
0.013 – 0.018 |
Oats combined ++ |
4526 |
22.95 – 30.00 |
0.0027 – 0.0035 |
0.014 – 0.018 |
Adult Vegetarians / Vegans (19-64 years) (n=170)
Food groups |
Count of T-2 HT-2 data call samples (n) |
Median T-2/HT-2 concentration µg/kg LB-UB |
Mean* |
P97.5* |
Processed oats** |
443 |
25 |
0.0035 |
0.021 |
Unprocessed oats with reduction factor+ |
4083 |
22.20-30.00 |
0.0031 – 0.0042 |
0.018 – 0.025 |
Oats combined ++ |
4526 |
22.95 – 30.00 |
0.0032 – 0.0042 |
0.019 – 0.025 |
Women of Childbearing age (16-49 years) (n=2556)
Food groups |
Count of T-2 HT-2 data call samples (n) |
Median T-2/HT-2 concentration µg/kg LB-UB |
Mean* |
P97.5* |
Processed oats** |
443 |
25 |
0.0018 |
0.012 |
Unprocessed oats with reduction factor+ |
4083 |
22.20-30.00 |
0.0016 – 0.0022 |
0.011 – 0.014 |
Oats combined ++ |
4526 |
22.95 – 30.00 |
0.0017 – 0.0022 |
0.011 – 0.014 |
*Estimates have been rounded to 2 significant figures.
+Oat grains with reduction factor - unprocessed oat grains with reduction factor applied.
**Processed oat grains – RPC derivatives/ ingredients i.e. RPCs which have undergone basic processing such as grinding, milling or crushing.
++ Oats combined - combination of processed oat grains and unprocessed oat grains with reduction factor (85%).
LB - Lower bound: values below the limit of quantification (LOQ) are treated as zero; UB - Upper bound: values below the LOQ are treated as at the LOQ.
** If single value is shown, it indicates that the exposures are based on detected values above the LOQ.
Acute exposure
48. Table 5 shows the acute exposures from oat grains, i.e. processed oat grains, unprocessed oat grains with a reduction factor applied and oats combined.
49. For processed oat grains the lowest acute exposures were in women of childbearing age (16-49 years) with mean and P97.5th percentile exposures of 0.0036 and 0.021 µg/kg bw, respectively, while the highest acute exposures were in infants (4-18 months) with mean and P97.5th percentile exposures of 0.015 and 0.085 µg/kg bw, respectively.
50. For oats combined, the lowest chronic exposures were in women of childbearing age (16-49 years) with mean and 97.5th percentile exposures of 0.0033-0.0043 (LB-UB) and 0.020-0.026 (LB-UB) µg/kg bw, respectively, while the highest chronic exposures were in infants (4-18 months) with mean and 97.5th percentile exposures of 0.014-0.018 (LB-UB) and 0.078-0.10 (LB-UB) µg/kg bw, respectively. Toddlers has similar exposures to infants.
51. Application of a reduction factor of 85% to the levels obtained for unprocessed oat grains resulted in similar exposures to data submitted for processed oat grains (LB) for all population groups.
Table 4: Acute exposure to sum of T-2 and HT-2 from processed oat grains, unprocessed oat grains with applied reduction factor, and oats combined based on DNSYIC and NDNS years 1-11 consumption data and occurrence data collected from the FSA call for evidence (µg/kg bw/day; LB-UB).
Infants (4-18 months) (n=2683)
Food groups |
Count of T-2 HT-2 data call samples (n) |
Median T-2/HT-2 concentration µg/kg LB-UB |
Mean* |
P97.5* |
Processed oats** |
443 |
25 |
0.015 |
0.085 |
Unprocessed oats with reduction factor+ |
4083 |
22.20-30.00 |
0.013-0.018 |
0.075-0.10 |
Oats combined++ |
4526 |
22.95 – 30.00 |
0.014-0.018 |
0.078-0.10 |
Toddlers (1.5-3 years) (n=1157)
Food groups |
Count of T-2 HT-2 data call samples (n) |
Median T-2/HT-2 concentration µg/kg LB-UB |
Mean* |
P97.5* |
Processed oats** |
443 |
25 |
0.014 |
0.079 |
Unprocessed oats with reduction factor+ |
4083 |
22.20-30.00 |
0.013 – 0.017 |
0.070 – 0.094 |
Oats combined++ |
4526 |
22.95 – 30.00 |
0.013 – 0.017 |
0.072 – 0.094 |
Children (4-10 years) (n=2537)
Food groups |
Count of T-2 HT-2 data call samples (n) |
Median T-2/HT-2 concentration µg/kg LB-UB |
Mean* |
P97.5*
|
Processed oats** |
443 |
25 |
0.0092 |
0.049 |
Unprocessed oats with reduction factor+ |
4083 |
22.20-30.00 |
0.0081 – 0.011 |
0.043 – 0.059 |
Oats combined++ |
4526 |
22.95 – 30.00 |
0.0084 – 0.011 |
0.045 – 0.059 |
Older Children (11-18 years) (n=2657)
Food groups |
Count of T-2 HT-2 data call samples (n) |
Median T-2/HT-2 concentration µg/kg LB-UB |
Mean* |
P97.5* |
Processed oats** |
443 |
25 |
0.0037 |
0.023 |
Unprocessed oats with reduction factor+ |
4083 |
22.20-30.00 |
0.0033 – 0.0045 |
0.021 – 0.028 |
Oats combined++ |
4526 |
22.95 – 30.00 |
0.0034 – 0.0045 |
0.021 – 0.028 |
Adults (19-64 years) (n=5094)
Food groups |
Count of T-2 HT-2 data call samples (n) |
Median T-2/HT-2 concentration µg/kg LB-UB |
Mean* |
P97.5* |
Processed oats** |
443 |
25 |
0.0038 |
0.022 |
Unprocessed oats with reduction factor+ |
4083 |
22.20-30.00 |
0.0034 – 0.0046 |
0.020 – 0.027 |
Oats combined++ |
4526 |
22.95 – 30.00 |
0.0035 – 0.0046 |
0.021 – 0.027 |
Elderly (65+ years) (n=1538)
Food groups |
Count of T-2 HT-2 data call samples (n) |
Median T-2/HT-2 concentration µg/kg LB-UB |
Mean* |
P97.5* |
Processed oats** |
443 |
25 |
0.0047 |
0.022 |
Unprocessed oats with reduction factor+ |
4083 |
22.20-30.00 |
0.0042 – 0.0057 |
0.019 – 0.026 |
Oats combined++ |
4526 |
22.95 – 30.00 |
0.0043– 0.0057 |
0.020 – 0.026 |
Adult Vegetarians / Vegans (19-64 years) (n=170)
Food groups |
Count of T-2 HT-2 data call samples (n) |
Median T-2/HT-2 concentration µg/kg LB-UB |
Mean* |
P97.5* |
Processed oats** |
443 |
25 |
0.0069 |
0.035 |
Unprocessed oats with reduction factor+ |
4083 |
22.20-30.00 |
0.0061 – 0.0082 |
0.031 – 0.042 |
Oats combined++ |
4526 |
22.95 – 30.00 |
0.0063 – 0.0082 |
0.032 – 0.042 |
Women of Childbearing age (16-49 years) (n=2556)
Food groups |
Count of T-2 HT-2 data call samples (n) |
Median T-2/HT-2 concentration µg/kg LB-UB |
Mean* |
P97.5* |
Processed oats** |
443 |
25 |
0.0036 |
0.021 |
Unprocessed oats with reduction factor+ |
4083 |
22.20-30.00 |
0.0032 – 0.0043 |
0.019 – 0.026 |
Oats combined++ |
4526 |
22.95 – 30.00 |
0.0033 – 0.0043 |
0.020 – 0.026 |
*Estimates have been rounded to 2 significant figures.
+Oats with reduction factor - unprocessed oat grains with reduction factor applied.
**Processed oat grains – RPC derivatives/ ingredients i.e. RPCs which have undergone basic processing such as grinding, milling or crushing.
++ Oats combined - combination of processed oat grains and unprocessed oat grains with reduction factor (85%).
LB - Lower bound: values below the limit of quantification (LOQ) are treated as zero; UB - Upper bound: values below the LOQ are treated as at the LOQ.
** If single value is shown, it indicates that the exposures are based on detected values above the LOQ.
Total exposure from all grains
52. The total exposure from all grains was considered under two different scenarios and the data are presented in Tables 6-9, i.e. exposures from (i) the sum of processed barley grains, wheat grains and oat grains (Tables 6-7), and (ii) the sum of unprocessed barley grains, wheat grains, and oat grains (Tables 8-9).
53. The exposure from the sum of unprocessed grains was included for completeness, taking into account the cleaning and further suitability checks the data underwent. However, this is as a worst-case scenario and an overestimation of real-life exposures.
Processed grains
54. Tables 6 and 7 show the estimated exposures from processed barley grains, processed wheat grains, and oats combined (the sum of processed oat grains submitted by industry and unprocessed oat grains to which a reduction factor has been applied). Tables 6 and 7 also include the estimated exposures to the sum of all grains.
Chronic exposure
55. Table 6 shows that oats combined was the main contributor to the overall chronic exposure from all three grain types, in all population groups. Exposures from barley made the lowest contribution to the overall exposure.
56. The highest chronic estimated exposures to the sum of all processed grains were in infants (4-18 months) with mean and 97.5th percentile exposures of 0.0063-0.010 (LB- UB), and 0.039-0.052 (LB-UB) µg/kg bw, respectively, with toddlers having similar exposure estimates. The lowest chronic exposures were seen in older children with mean and 97.5th percentile exposures of 0.0015-0.0039 (LB-UB), and 0.010-0.017 (LB-UB) µg/kg bw, respectively.
Table 5: Chronic exposure to sum of T-2 and HT-2 from processed barley, oats combined (combination of processed oat grains and unprocessed oat grains with reduction factor) (RPC) and processed wheat based on DNSYIC and NDNS years 1-11 consumption data and occurrence data collected from the FSA call for evidence (µg/kg bw/day; LB-UB).
Infants (4-18 months) (n=2683)
Food groups |
Count of T-2 HT-2 data call samples (n) |
Median T-2/HT-2 concentration µg/kg LB-UB |
Mean* |
P97.5* |
Oats combined ++ |
4526 |
22.95 – 30.00 |
0.0063-0.0083 |
0.039-0.051 |
Processed wheat grains |
454 |
0 -2.00 |
0-0.0018 |
0-0.0062 |
Processed barley grains |
25 |
0 -10.00 |
0-0.00010 |
0-0.00055 |
All grains sum |
NA |
NA |
0.0063-0.010 |
0.039-0.052 |
Toddlers (1.5-3 years) (n=1157)
Food groups |
Count of T-2 HT-2 data call samples (n) |
Median T-2/HT-2 concentration µg/kg LB-UB |
Mean* |
P97.5* |
Oats combined ++ |
4526 |
22.95 – 30.00 |
0.0060 – 0.0078 |
0.038 – 0.050 |
Processed wheat grains |
454 |
0 -2.00 |
0-0.0032 |
0-0.0080 |
Processed barley grains |
25 |
0 -10.00 |
0- 0.00013 |
0- 0.0011 |
All grains sum |
NA |
NA |
0.0060-0.011 |
0.038-0.053 |
Children (4-10 years) (n=2537)
Food groups |
Count of T-2 HT-2 data call samples (n) |
Median T-2/HT-2 concentration µg/kg LB-UB |
Mean* |
P97.5*
|
Oats combined ++ |
4526 |
22.95 – 30.00 |
0.0038 – 0.0050 |
0.023 – 0.031 |
Processed wheat grains |
454 |
0 -2.00 |
0-0.0031 |
0- 0.0073 |
Processed barley grains |
25 |
0 -10.00 |
0- 0.00010 |
0- 0.00082 |
All grains sum |
NA |
NA |
0.0038-0.0082 |
0.023-0.035 |
Older Children (11-18 years) (n=2657)
Food groups |
Count of T-2 HT-2 data call samples (n) |
Median T-2/HT-2 concentration µg/kg LB-UB |
Mean* |
P97.5* |
Oats combined ++ |
4526 |
22.95 – 30.00 |
0.0015 – 0.0019 |
0.010 – 0.013 |
Processed wheat grains |
454 |
0 -2.00 |
0-0.0018 |
0-0.0043 |
Processed barley grains |
25 |
0 -10.00 |
0- 0.00017 |
0- 0.00052 |
All grains sum |
NA |
NA |
0.0015-0.0039 |
0.010-0.017 |
Adults (19-64 years) (n=5094)
Food groups |
Count of T-2 HT-2 data call samples (n) |
Median T-2/HT-2 concentration µg/kg LB-UB |
Mean* |
P97.5* |
Oats combined ++ |
4526 |
22.95 – 30.00 |
0.0019 – 0.0024 |
0.013 – 0.017 |
Processed wheat grains |
454 |
0 -2.00 |
0-0.0011 |
0-0.0029 |
Processed barley grains |
25 |
0 -10.00 |
0-0.0039 |
0- 0.052 |
All grains sum |
NA |
NA |
0.0019-0.0075 |
0.013-0.059 |
Elderly (65+ years) (n=1538)
Food groups |
Count of T-2 HT-2 data call samples (n) |
Median T-2/HT-2 concentration µg/kg LB-UB |
Mean* |
P97.5* |
Oats combined ++ |
4526 |
22.95 – 30.00 |
0.0027 – 0.0035 |
0.014 – 0.018 |
Processed wheat grains |
454 |
0 -2.00 |
0-0.00097 |
0-0.0024 |
Processed barley grains |
25 |
0 -10.00 |
0-0.0054 |
0-0.071 |
All grains sum |
NA |
NA |
0.0027-0.0099 |
0.014-0.075 |
Adult Vegetarians / Vegans (19-64 years) (n=170)
Food groups |
Count of T-2 HT-2 data call samples (n) |
Median T-2/HT-2 concentration µg/kg LB-UB |
Mean* |
P97.5* |
Oats combined ++ |
4526 |
22.95 – 30.00 |
0.0032 – 0.0042 |
0.019 – 0.025 |
Processed wheat grains |
454 |
0 -2.00 |
0-0.0013 |
0-0.0031 |
Processed barley grains |
25 |
0 -10.00 |
0-0.0036 |
0-0.035 |
All grains sum |
NA |
NA |
0.0032-0.0091 |
0.019-0.047 |
Women of Childbearing age (16-49 years) (n=2556)
Food groups |
Count of T-2 HT-2 data call samples (n) |
Median T-2/HT-2 concentration µg/kg LB-UB |
Mean* |
P97.5* |
Oats combined ++ |
4526 |
22.95 – 30.00 |
0.0017 – 0.0022 |
0.011 – 0.014 |
Processed wheat grains |
454 |
0 -2.00 |
0-0.0011 |
0-0.0028 |
Processed barley grains |
25 |
0 -10.00 |
0- 0.00061 |
0-0.0010 |
All grains sum |
NA |
NA |
0.0017-0.0039 |
0.011-0.019 |
*Estimates have been rounded to 2 significant figures.
++ Oats combined - combination of processed oat grains and unprocessed oat grains with reduction factor (identical to “Oats combined” from Table 4 above).
LB - Lower bound: values below the limit of quantification (LOQ) are treated as zero; UB - Upper bound: values below the LOQ are treated as at the LOQ.
Acute exposure
57. Table 7 shows that as for chronic exposures, for acute exposures, oats combined was the main contributor to the overall exposure derived for all three grain types, in all population groups. Exposures from barley made the lowest contribution to the overall exposure.
58. For the sum of all processed grains the highest acute exposure estimates were in infants (4-18 months) with mean and 97.5th percentile exposures of 0.014-0.021 (LB-UB), and 0.078-0.10 (LB-UB) µg/kg bw, respectively, exposures in toddlers (1.5-3 years) were similar. The lowest acute exposure estimates were in women of childbearing age (16-49 years) with mean and 97.5th percentile exposures of 0.0033-0.0082 (LB-UB), and 0.020-0.034 (LB-UB) µg/kg bw, respectively.
Table 6: Acute exposure to sum of T-2 and HT-2 from processed barley, oats combined (combination of processed oat grains and unprocessed oat grains with reduction factor), and processed wheat based on DNSYIC and NDNS years 1-11 consumption data and occurrence data collected from the FSA call for evidence (µg/kg bw/day; LB-UB).
Infants (4-18 months) (n=2683)
Food groups |
Count of T-2 HT-2 data call samples (n) |
Median T-2/HT-2 concentration µg/kg LB-UB |
Mean* |
P97.5* |
Oats combined ++ |
4526 |
22.95 – 30.00 |
0.014-0.018 |
0.078-0.10 |
Processed wheat |
454 |
0 -2.00 |
0-0.0035 |
0-0.011 |
Processed barley grains |
25 |
0 -10.00 |
0-0.00031 |
0-0.0016 |
All grains |
NA |
NA |
0.014-0.021 |
0.078-0.10 |
Toddlers (1.5-3 years) (n=1157)
Food groups |
Count of T-2 HT-2 data call samples (n) |
Median T-2/HT-2 concentration µg/kg LB-UB |
Mean* |
P97.5* |
Oats combined ++ |
4526 |
22.95 – 30.00 |
0.013 – 0.017 |
0.072 – 0.094 |
Processed wheat |
454 |
0 -2.00 |
0-0.0058 |
0-0.014 |
Processed barley grains |
25 |
0 -10.00 |
0- 0.00038 |
0- 0.0036 |
All grains |
NA |
NA |
0.013-0.022 |
0.072-0.097 |
Children (4-10 years) (n=2537)
Food groups |
Count of T-2 HT-2 data call samples (n) |
Median T-2/HT-2 concentration µg/kg LB-UB |
Mean* |
P97.5*
|
Oats combined ++ |
4526 |
22.95 – 30.00 |
0.0084 – 0.011 |
0.045 – 0.059 |
Processed wheat |
454 |
0 -2.00 |
0-0.0054 |
0- 0.012 |
Processed barley grains |
25 |
0 -10.00 |
0- 0.00027 |
0- 0.0022 |
All grains |
NA |
NA |
0.0084-0.016 |
0.045-0.062 |
Older Children (11-18 years) (n=2657)
Food groups |
Count of T-2 HT-2 data call samples (n) |
Median T-2/HT-2 concentration µg/kg LB-UB |
Mean* |
P97.5* |
Oats combined ++ |
4526 |
22.95 – 30.00 |
0.0034 – 0.0045 |
0.021 – 0.028 |
Processed wheat |
454 |
0 -2.00 |
0-0.0033 |
0-0.0081 |
Processed barley grains |
25 |
0 -10.00 |
0- 0.00058 |
0- 0.0013 |
All grains |
NA |
NA |
0.0034-0.0077 |
0.021-0.032 |
Adults (19-64 years) (n=5094)
Food groups |
Count of T-2 HT-2 data call samples (n) |
Median T-2/HT-2 concentration µg/kg LB-UB |
Mean* |
P97.5* |
Oats combined ++ |
4526 |
22.95 – 30.00 |
0.0035 – 0.0046 |
0.021 – 0.027 |
Processed wheat |
454 |
0 -2.00 |
0-0.0022 |
0-0.0055 |
Processed barley grains |
25 |
0 -10.00 |
0-0.011 |
0- 0.16 |
All grains |
NA |
NA |
0.0035-0.017 |
0.021-0.16 |
Elderly (65+ years) (n=1538)
Food groups |
Count of T-2 HT-2 data call samples (n) |
Median T-2/HT-2 concentration µg/kg LB-UB |
Mean* |
P97.5* |
Oats combined ++ |
4526 |
22.95 – 30.00 |
0.0043– 0.0057 |
0.020 – 0.026 |
Processed wheat |
454 |
0 -2.00 |
0-0.0017 |
0-0.0040 |
Processed barley grains |
25 |
0 -10.00 |
0-0.013 |
0-0.18 |
All grains |
NA |
NA |
0.0043-0.020 |
0.020-0.19 |
Adult Vegetarians / Vegans (19-64 years) (n=170)
Food groups |
Count of T-2 HT-2 data call samples (n) |
Median T-2/HT-2 concentration µg/kg LB-UB |
Mean* |
P97.5* |
Oats combined ++ |
4526 |
22.95 – 30.00 |
0.0063 – 0.0082 |
0.032 – 0.042 |
Processed wheat |
454 |
0 -2.00 |
0-0.0025 |
0-0.0053 |
Processed barley grains |
25 |
0 -10.00 |
0-0.014 |
0-0.11 |
All grains |
NA |
NA |
0.0063-0.024 |
0.032-0.12 |
Women of Childbearing age (16-49 years) (n=2556)
Food groups |
Count of T-2 HT-2 data call samples (n) |
Median T-2/HT-2 concentration µg/kg LB-UB |
Mean* |
P97.5* |
Oats combined ++ |
4526 |
22.95 – 30.00 |
0.0033 – 0.0043 |
0.020 – 0.026 |
Processed wheat |
454 |
0 -2.00 |
0-0.0022 |
0-0.0057 |
Processed barley grains |
25 |
0 -10.00 |
0- 0.0021 |
0-0.0023 |
All grains |
NA |
NA |
0.0033-0.0082 |
0.020-0.034 |
*Estimates have been rounded to 2 significant figures.
++ Oats combined - combination of processed oat grains and unprocessed oat grains with reduction factor (identical to “Oats combined” from Table 5 above).
LB - Lower bound: values below the limit of quantification (LOQ) are treated as zero; UB - Upper bound: values below the LOQ are treated as at the LOQ.
All unprocessed grains
59. Table 8 and Table 9 provide the estimated exposures to the sum off all three grain types, unprocessed.
Chronic exposure
60. Table 8 provides an estimate of the worst-case scenario as it shows the estimated chronic exposures of the sum of T-2 and HT-2 from all three grain types in their unprocessed form. The data shows that across all age groups, the lowest contribution to the overall exposure was from unprocessed barley. Unprocessed oat grains made the highest contribution to the overall.
61. The highest chronic exposure estimates for the sum of all three grain types were in infants (4-18 months) and toddlers (1.5-3 years), with a mean and 97.5th percentile exposure of 0-0.056/0.061 (LB-UB) and 0-0.29 (LB-UB) µg/kg bw, respectively. The lowest chronic exposure estimates were in older children (11-18 years), with a mean and 97.5th percentile exposure of 0-0.020 (LB-UB) and 0-0.089 (LB-UB) µg/kg bw, respectively.
Table 7: Chronic exposure to sum of T-2 and HT-2 from unprocessed oat grains, unprocessed wheat grains, and unprocessed barley grains based on DNSYIC and NDNS years 1-11 consumption data and occurrence data collected from the FSA call for evidence (µg/kg bw/day; LB-UB).
Infants (4-18 months) (n=2683)
Food groups |
Count of T-2 HT-2 data call samples (n) |
Median T-2/HT-2 concentration µg/kg LB-UB |
Mean* |
P97.5* |
Unprocessed oats** |
4083 |
170.44 |
0.047 |
0.29 |
Unprocessed wheat grains |
192 |
0 -10.00 |
0-0.0091 |
0-0.031 |
Unprocessed barley grains |
105 |
0 -10.00 |
0-0.00010 |
0-0.00055 |
All grains sum |
NA |
NA |
0-0.056 |
0-0.29 |
Toddlers (1.5-3 years) (n=1157)
Food groups |
Count of T-2 HT-2 data call samples (n) |
Median T-2/HT-2 concentration µg/kg LB-UB |
Mean* |
P97.5* |
Unprocessed oats** |
4083 |
170.44 |
0.044 |
0.28 |
Unprocessed wheat grains |
192 |
0 -10.00 |
0-0.016 |
0-0.040 |
Unprocessed barley grains |
105 |
0 -10.00 |
0- 0.00013 |
0- 0.0011 |
All grains sum |
NA |
NA |
0-0.061 |
0-0.29 |
Children (4-10 years) (n=2537)
Food groups |
Count of T-2 HT-2 data call samples (n) |
Median T-2/HT-2 concentration µg/kg LB-UB |
Mean* |
P97.5*
|
Unprocessed oats** |
4083 |
170.44 |
0.028 |
0.17 |
Unprocessed wheat grains |
192 |
0 -10.00 |
0-0.015 |
0- 0.036 |
Unprocessed barley grains |
105 |
0 -10.00 |
0- 0.00010 |
0- 0.00082 |
All grains sum |
NA |
NA |
0-0.044 |
0-0.20 |
Older Children (11-18 years) (n=2657)
Food groups |
Count of T-2 HT-2 data call samples (n) |
Median T-2/HT-2 concentration µg/kg LB-UB |
Mean* |
P97.5* |
Unprocessed oats** |
4083 |
170.44 |
0.011 |
0.076 |
Unprocessed wheat grains |
192 |
0 -10.00 |
0-0.0089 |
0-0.022 |
Unprocessed barley grains |
105 |
0 -10.00 |
0- 0.00017 |
0- 0.00052 |
All grains sum |
NA |
NA |
0-0.020 |
0-0.089 |
Adults (19-64 years) (n=5094)
Food groups |
Count of T-2 HT-2 data call samples (n) |
Median T-2/HT-2 concentration µg/kg LB-UB |
Mean* |
P97.5* |
Unprocessed oats** |
4083 |
170.44 |
0.014 |
0.095 |
Unprocessed wheat grains |
192 |
0 -10.00 |
0-0.0056 |
0-0.015 |
Unprocessed barley grains |
105 |
0 -10.00 |
0-0.0039 |
0- 0.052 |
All grains sum |
NA |
NA |
0-0.023 |
0-0.12 |
Elderly (65+ years) (n=1538)
Food groups |
Count of T-2 HT-2 data call samples (n) |
Median T-2/HT-2 concentration µg/kg LB-UB |
Mean* |
P97.5* |
Unprocessed oats** |
4083 |
170.44 |
0.020 |
0.10 |
Unprocessed wheat grains |
192 |
0 -10.00 |
0-0.0048 |
0-0.012 |
Unprocessed barley grains |
105 |
0 -10.00 |
0-0.0054 |
0-0.071 |
All grains sum |
NA |
NA |
0-0.030 |
0-0.15 |
Adult Vegetarians / Vegans (19-64 years) (n=170)
Food groups |
Count of T-2 HT-2 data call samples (n) |
Median T-2/HT-2 concentration µg/kg LB-UB |
Mean* |
P97.5* |
Unprocessed oats** |
4083 |
170.44 |
0.024 |
0.14 |
Unprocessed wheat grains |
192 |
0 -10.00 |
0-0.0063 |
0-0.015 |
Unprocessed barley grains |
105 |
0 -10.00 |
0-0.0036 |
0-0.035 |
All grains sum |
NA |
NA |
0-0.034 |
0-0.15 |
Women of Childbearing age (16-49 years) (n=2556)
Food groups |
Count of T-2 HT-2 data call samples (n) |
Median T-2/HT-2 concentration µg/kg LB-UB |
Mean* |
P97.5* |
Unprocessed oats** |
4083 |
170.44 |
0.012 |
0.081 |
Unprocessed wheat grains |
192 |
0 -10.00 |
0-0.0057 |
0-0.014 |
Unprocessed barley grains |
105 |
0 -10.00 |
0- 0.00061 |
0-0.0010 |
All grains sum |
NA |
NA |
0-0.019 |
0-0.093 |
*Estimates have been rounded to 2 significant figures.
**Unprocessed oat grains – oat grains without processing (raw primary commodity (RPC)).
LB - Lower bound: values below the limit of quantification (LOQ) are treated as zero; UB - Upper bound: values below the LOQ are treated as at the LOQ.
** If single value is shown, it indicates that the exposures are based on detected values above the LOQ.
Acute exposure
62. Table 9 provides a worst-case scenario with estimated acute exposures of the sum of all unprocessed grains. As with chronic exposure estimates, the data shows that across all age groups, the lowest contribution to the exposure was from unprocessed barley while the highest contribution was from unprocessed oat grains.
63. The highest acute exposure estimates to the sum of all three grain types were in infants (4-18 months) and toddlers (1.5-3 years) with mean and 97.5th percentile exposures of 0-0.12 (LB-UB) and 0-0.59/0.055 (LB-UB) µg/kg bw, respectively, while the lowest acute exposure was in women of childbearing age (19-64 years) with mean and 97.5th percentile exposures of 0-0.035 (LB-UB) and 0-0.17 (LB-UB) µg/kg bw, respectively.
Table 8: Acute exposure to sum of T-2 and HT-2 from unprocessed oat grains, unprocessed wheat grains, and unprocessed barley grains based on DNSYIC and NDNS years 1-11 consumption data and occurrence data collected from the FSA call for evidence (µg/kg bw/day; LB-UB).
Infants (4-18 months) (n=2683)
Food groups |
Count of T-2 HT-2 data call samples (n) |
Median T-2/HT-2 concentration µg/kg LB-UB |
Mean* |
P97.5* |
Unprocessed oats** |
4083 |
170.44 |
0.10 |
0.58 |
Unprocessed wheat grains |
192 |
0 -10.00 |
0-0.018 |
0-0.056 |
Unprocessed barley grains |
105 |
0 -10.00 |
0-0.00031 |
0-0.0016 |
All grains |
NA |
NA |
0-0.12 |
0-0.59 |
Toddlers (1.5-3 years) (n=1157)
Food groups |
Count of T-2 HT-2 data call samples (n) |
Median T-2/HT-2 concentration µg/kg LB-UB |
Mean* |
P97.5* |
Unprocessed oats** |
4083 |
170.44 |
0.096 |
0.54 |
Unprocessed wheat grains |
192 |
0 -10.00 |
0-0.029 |
0-0.069 |
Unprocessed barley grains |
105 |
0 -10.00 |
0- 0.00038 |
0- 0.0036 |
All grains |
NA |
NA |
0-0.12 |
0-0.55 |
Children (4-10 years) (n=2537)
Food groups |
Count of T-2 HT-2 data call samples (n) |
Median T-2/HT-2 concentration µg/kg LB-UB |
Mean* |
P97.5*
|
Unprocessed oats** |
4083 |
170.44 |
0.063 |
0.33 |
Unprocessed wheat grains |
192 |
0 -10.00 |
0-0.027 |
0- 0.062 |
Unprocessed barley grains |
105 |
0 -10.00 |
0- 0.00027 |
0- 0.0022 |
All grains |
NA |
NA |
0-0.084 |
0-0.35 |
Older Children (11-18 years) (n=2657)
Food groups |
Count of T-2 HT-2 data call samples (n) |
Median T-2/HT-2 concentration µg/kg LB-UB |
Mean* |
P97.5* |
Unprocessed oats** |
4083 |
170.44 |
0.025 |
0.16 |
Unprocessed wheat grains |
192 |
0 -10.00 |
0-0.016 |
0-0.040 |
Unprocessed barley grains |
105 |
0 -10.00 |
0- 0.00058 |
0- 0.0013 |
All grains |
NA |
NA |
0-0.040 |
0-0.17 |
Adults (19-64 years) (n=5094)
Food groups |
Count of T-2 HT-2 data call samples (n) |
Median T-2/HT-2 concentration µg/kg LB-UB |
Mean* |
P97.5* |
Unprocessed oats** |
4083 |
170.44 |
0.026 |
0.15 |
Unprocessed wheat grains |
192 |
0 -10.00 |
0-0.011 |
0-0.028 |
Unprocessed barley grains |
105 |
0 -10.00 |
0-0.011 |
0- 0.16 |
All grains |
NA |
NA |
0-0.045 |
0-0.24 |
Elderly (65+ years) (n=1538)
Food groups |
Count of T-2 HT-2 data call samples (n) |
Median T-2/HT-2 concentration µg/kg LB-UB |
Mean* |
P97.5* |
Unprocessed oats** |
4083 |
170.44 |
0.032 |
0.15 |
Unprocessed wheat grains |
192 |
0 -10.00 |
0-0.0084 |
0-0.020 |
Unprocessed barley grains |
105 |
0 -10.00 |
0-0.013 |
0-0.18 |
All grains |
NA |
NA |
0-0.051 |
0-0.24 |
Adult Vegetarians / Vegans (19-64 years) (n=170)
Food groups |
Count of T-2 HT-2 data call samples (n) |
Median T-2/HT-2 concentration µg/kg LB-UB |
Mean* |
P97.5* |
Unprocessed oats** |
4083 |
170.44 |
0.047 |
0.24 |
Unprocessed wheat grains |
192 |
0 -10.00 |
0-0.012 |
0-0.027 |
Unprocessed barley grains |
105 |
0 -10.00 |
0-0.014 |
0-0.11 |
All grains |
NA |
NA |
0-0.069 |
0-0.34 |
Women of Childbearing age (16-49 years) (n=2556)
Food groups |
Count of T-2 HT-2 data call samples (n) |
Median T-2/HT-2 concentration µg/kg LB-UB |
Mean* |
P97.5* |
Unprocessed oats** |
4083 |
170.44 |
0.024 |
0.15 |
Unprocessed wheat grains |
192 |
0 -10.00 |
0-0.011 |
0-0.028 |
Unprocessed barley grains |
105 |
0 -10.00 |
0- 0.0021 |
0-0.0023 |
All grains |
NA |
NA |
0-0.035 |
0-0.17 |
*Estimates have been rounded to 2 significant figures.
**Unprocessed oat grains – oat grains without processing (raw primary commodity (RPC)).
LB - Lower bound: values below the limit of quantification (LOQ) are treated as zero; UB - Upper bound: values below the LOQ are treated as at the LOQ.
** If single value is shown, it indicates that the exposures are based on detected values above the LOQ.
Exposure from ready to eat (RTE) foods
64. Consumer-based exposure estimates were caried out for infants (4-18 months), toddlers (1.5-3 years), adults (19-64 years), and adult vegetarians/vegans (19-64 years) from RTE foods. The chronic and acute exposure estimates are presented in Annex 1 and Annex 2, brief summaries of the exposures are provided here.
65. The estimated exposures are the mean and 97.5th percentile exposures based on the mean and maximum concentration (mean-max concentration) of T-2 or HT-2 or the sum of both, where available. Exposures to T-2 or HT-2 only were predominantly used as very few datapoints were available overall for RTE foods and even fewer on the sum of T-2 and HT-2.
Sum of T-2 and HT-2 exposure estimates
66. Data for the sum of T-2 and HT-2 were only available for infant cereals. Exposure to the sum of T-2 and HT-2 in this group are presented in Annex 1A and Annex 1B for chronic and acute exposure, respectively.
67. In brief, the highest mean and 97.5th percentile exposures, both for chronic and acute were in infants (4-18 months). Mean and 97.5th percentile chronic exposures were 0.36-0.71 µg/kg bw (mean-max concentration), and 1.5-2.9 µg/kg bw (mean-max concentration) µg/kg bw, respectively, while mean and 97.5th percentile acute exposure were 0.71-1.4 µg/kg bw (mean-max concentration), and 2.6-5.2 µg/kg bw (mean-max concentration) µg/kg bw respectively. However, chronic exposures in toddlers (1.5-3 years) still ranged from 0.22 µg/kg bw (mean) to 1.4 µg/kg bw (97.5th percentile and from 0.52 µg/kg bw (mean) to 2.6 µg/kg bw (97.5th percentile) for acute exposures.
T-2 or HT2 exposure estimates only
68. Where there were limited data on the sum of T-2 and HT-2 from RTE foods for an exposure assessment, the data on individually reported levels of T-2 or HT-2 were used.
Chronic exposure estimates to T-2
69. The highest chronic exposure estimates to T-2 from RTE foods were from oat porridge in infants (4-18 months) with mean and 97.5th percentile exposures of 0.033-0.10 (mean-max concentration), and 0.17-0.51 (mean-max concentration) µg/kg bw, respectively. The lowest chronic exposure estimates to T-2 from RTE foods were from plain muesli in infants (4-18 months) with mean and 97.5th percentile exposures of 0.0030-0.0043 (mean-max concentration), and 0.001-0.0015 (mean-max concentration) ng/kg bw, respectively (Annex 2A).
Acute exposure estimates to T-2
70. The highest acute exposure estimates for T-2 from RTE foods were from oat porridge in infants (4-18 months), with mean and 97.5th percentile exposures of 0.074-0.23 (mean-max concentration), and 0.27-0.83 (mean-max concentration) µg/kg bw, respectively. The lowest acute exposure estimates to T-2 from RTE foods were from plain muesli in infants (4-18 months) with mean and 97.5th percentile of 0.00073-0.0011 (mean-max concentration), and 0.0025-0.0036 (mean-max concentration) µg/kg bw, respectively (Annex 2B).
Chronic exposure estimates to HT-2
71. The highest chronic exposure estimates for HT-2 from RTE foods were from infant cereals, in infants (4-18 months), with mean and 97.5th percentile exposures of 0.70-0.71 (mean-max concentration), and 2.9-2.9 (mean-max concentration) µg/kg bw, respectively. The lowest chronic exposure estimates for HT-2 from RTE foods were from puffs/curls and extruded snacks in adults (19-64 years) with mean and 97.5th percentile exposures of 0.00064-0.00064 (mean-max concentration), and 0.0020-0.0020 (mean-max concentration) µg/kg bw, respectively (Annex 2C).
Acute exposure estimates to HT-2
72. The highest acute exposure estimates to HT-2 from RTE foods were from infant cereals, in infants (4-18 months), with mean and 97.5th percentile exposures of 1.4-1.4 (mean-max concentration), and 5.2-5.2 (mean-max concentration) µg/kg bw, respectively. The lowest acute exposure estimates from HT-2 from RTE foods were from puffs/curls and extruded snacks in adults (19-64 years) with mean and 97.5th percentile exposures of 0.0018-0.0018 (mean-max concentration), and 0.0050-0.0050 (mean-max concentration) µg/kg bw, respectively (Annex 2D).